ice cream cake

My ice cream cake, in all its un-iced glory.

Perhaps it speaks to my nature that, on the eve of my 27th orbit around the sun, I am posting about a cake I made for someone else’s birthday. But — onward.

This has been a year of insane growth, in which I’ve reinvented myself several times over. My friends have come to know (and name) my alter egos.

There’s Bad Jules, or BJ for short. Formerly known as Party Jules, BJ is the wild mustang who comes out after a drink or two. She is responsible for many fun nights, Ubers of shame, hungover mornings, and one (relatively uneventful) experience blacking out (oops). I embrace BJ with all my heart, as she is the person I once was in my younger, study-abroad years and have since neglected. She is the id to my ego, the Sasha Fierce to my Beyonce, the Miley Cyrus to my Hannah Montana.

There’s also Productive Jules (PJ), that version of myself who actually gets shit done. You can find her in one of a few beloved coffee shops, at a corner table, earbuds in, typing notes frantically, papers strewn all over the table. It is thanks to PJ that I’ve passed classes, written book chapters, and (mostly) checked all my emails. She is the functional piece of me who does all the adult-ing of which I am capable.

Finally, there is Mama Jules. This, perhaps, is the alter ego truest to my real self: the person who loves to take care of others. My lab knows to expect baked goods with every birthday. My colleagues know that I will make a signature batch of roasted broccoli for every event. My friends know that I will heat up leftovers for them if they come over (and Mama Jules always has leftovers). As I was told recently, cooking for someone else is the ultimate form of affection, in that it involves actual nourishment of a body. That lovin’ maternal instinct is what drives me to make and share food.

It is with great care, then, that I made an ice cream cake for a birthday. I’d considered baking an actual cake, but my (school-dominated) schedule and (grad student stipend-funded) pantry are not what they used to be. I gotta say, though… Though I personally thought this ice cream cake was a misshapen cop-out, everyone else in the room seemed duly impressed when I brought it out. People were mystified at how I managed to transform gallons of dairy into a big ol’ birthday dessert. It still comes up in conversation months later. I guess that’s what happens when you do anything involving ice cream.

My own birthday festivities will certainly involve indulgence — hopefully involving an equivalently copious amount of ice cream, in addition to beer and pizza, at a sweet new biergarten here in HTX. More importantly, though, I’ll be ringing it in with people who I’ve come to care about and vice versa. Late twenties… I’m ready for ya. I think.

Ice cream cake

Recipe from the Kitchn

I am a fan if ice cream cakes that contain actual cake in them — but, alas, that is way too much fucking work for something that is supposed to be a bit of a shortcut. This Carvel-type version works just as beautifully: layers of cookie, cake, and chocolate syrup. No one will complain that it doesn’t remind them of their Baskin-Robbins standby. And if they do, cut them out of your life.

For each layer you are building onto the cake, you will need (ideally) about 4 hours to let it set. Add on another 4 hours for the “icing” of the cake, though preferably you’ll be able to store it overnight to let it fully harden. I started this ice cream cake 24 hours before it was to be served. I am guilty of not always reading recipes thoroughly beforehand (terrible habit! Do as I say and not as I do!) — but, in this case, I urgently recommend reading the directions fully before starting. Timing is everything here. It is imperative that the cake stay as cold as possible, and that you minimize the prep time on the countertop!

Finally, I scaled the recipe up slightly and non-exactly from the original (which you should totally follow, since it’s much more technical than mine!). However, since you’re really just building a sundae, you can get creative and imprecise with measurements. At the end of the day, you’re eating ice cream and cookies… so yeah.


  • Large pot, chilled in the freezer (I used my Instant Pot insert)
  • Medium mixing bowl, chilled in the freezer
  • Serving platter (wider than the circumference of the large pot)


  • 3 quarts of ice cream of your choice (I used one each of chocolate, pistachio, and vanilla)
  • For the cookie layer
    • Two boxes (26 total ounces) of chocolate wafer cookies (I used Newman’s O’s)
    • One bottle (15.8 ounces) of chocolate syrup
  • For the whipped topping
    • 16 ounces of heavy whipping cream, chilled


  1. Line a big container (large enough to contain all 3 quarts of ice cream) with parchment paper, both the bottom and the sides. I cut out a circle for the bottom, initially laying the pot on top of the paper and tracing the outside to get a ballpark estimate — and then cut a long rectangle to fit against the sides. Put it in the freezer until it gets super cold.
  2. Take your chocolate wafer cookies and crush them into big pieces (not too little!). You can do this by putting them in a Ziploc baggie and hitting them with a heavy spoon or rolling pin. Divide this into two portions, leaving a little bit leftover (either crushed cookie pieces or whole cookies) for the topping.
  3. Create each layer of your ice cream cake!
    1. Take out your first quart of ice cream from the freezer and let soften on the countertop until it’s easily scoop-able.
    2. Take your container out from the freezer.
    3. Scoop all the ice cream into the container, quickly!
    4. Spread one portion of the crushed cookies on top of the ice cream layer, evenly.
    5. Grab your chocolate syrup and squeeze some on, evenly and across the cookie layer.
    6. Throw the whole thing back into the freezer. Wait for it to set (ideally four hours) before making the next layer of the cake.
  4. Once you’re done with the third and final layer of ice cream, you won’t have any cookies to put on top of it. Instead, we will cover it (and the rest of the cake) with icing. I used whipped cream, but I might recommend frosting or a ready-made topping if you’re interested in saving time/angst. Either way, here’s what I did while the ice cream cake itself is setting in the freezer:
    1. In your chilled mixing bowl, whip the heavy cream until stiff peaks form. I used an electric mixer to spare my wrists, but you can also use a whisk and a ton of elbow grease.
  5. And finally, to ice the cake itself.
    1. Take the container out of the freezer. We now want to get the ice cream out of the container, so run a knife along the sides of the container (between the parchment paper and the actual container). I also briefly splashed warm water on the container to help loosen the ice cream cake from the sides. When the cake feels ready to let go, place the serving platter face-down on top of the container and flip the whole thing over. The ice cream cake should (hopefully) fall neatly down onto the serving platter. Take off the parchment paper lining it and throw the thing back into the fridge to let it set!
    2. When you’re ready, grab the whipped cream and start spreading it on the cake with a flat spatula. (I had a lot of trouble here, since my cream was melting at a scary pace, but it still turned out okay).
    3. Freeze the dang thing again. For a long time. Preferably overnight.
  6. Decorate as you wish! (And then freeze it again, probably).
  7. When it’s time to serve, let it soften for a few minutes. It’s easiest to cut into it with a knife that you’ve run in warm water… but you can also just dig in with a fork, if you’re so inclined.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s